This week marks a monumental turning point for young people in Britain: finally they will come first, not last. An end, we must hope, to a perverse system that casts down the future generation and overrewards the already privileged old.
There are 1 million Neets (16- to 24-year-olds not in education, employment or training) in the UK, and they are partly George Osborne’s progeny. He targeted the young, tearing down the Connexions youth service, careers guidance, youth clubs, family benefits and further education funding. Michael Gove, with his Gradgrind exam fixation, scythed through music, sports, arts, drama and technology – subjects that kept many engaged with school. Remember the playing fields sold, the leisure centres closed, the mental health services for Covid-scarred children cut back. That created a lost generation, but it’s worse than that: Neets are blamed and scorned for what older generations have done to them. Labour’s intent is to prioritise the young from babyhood. Let that begin here.
It is the central purpose and the meaning of Tuesday’s report by Alan Milburn, commissioned by Keir Starmer and keenly adopted by Andy Burnham. This is the hardest of social projects, yet the government nonetheless sets itself to be judged by it, despite the high upfront cost, with no payback for years.
How will this land? There will, no doubt, be protest from right and left. But never was a policy so pitch-rolled as to flatten critics and sceptics with undeniable evidence that it will be to the good. There is a cornucopia of plans for schools, colleges, the NHS, councils and early years education. Ideas come from visits to see what works elsewhere, notably the Netherlands and Denmark. Seeing far fewer Neets in those countries, Milburn asked what they did about school and college drop-outs. “They didn’t understand that term,” he tells me. In those countries, if children start to struggle with school attendance, “they go straight round to find them and work out their problem. Here they disappear”.
Politically, this duty will fall on local mayors (or councils, where mayors have not yet been elected). Their colossal task is to pull together schools, FE colleges, jobcentres, NHS services and local employers. Heaving them out of their silos to collaborate will test mayoral devolution to its limits. With extra funding comes accountability for creating a continuous decline in the number of Neets in their area.
Everywhere, this will be delivered through youth hubs – welcoming places, “not jobcentres where they’re met by security guards, but places only for young people”, Milburn tells me. Last week he visited a model hub in Liverpool, Merseyside Youth Association. Hiring and training a new cohort of work coaches and advisers has begun, so hubs can offer supported internships, short flexi-jobs to ease into work and experience for those with none on their CVs. Incentives to employers to hire them may include cuts to employers’ national insurance contributions for those aged 21-24 in retail and hospitality. Ordinary earners under 21 are already NI-free.
GPs will not mourn the passing of the “fit notes” with which they were expected to sign people off work. That task goes to hubs’ community teams of occupational therapists, work coaches, mental health and job advisers, who offer counselling and personal “return to work plans” instead. Neets will be fast-tracked through NHS mental health queues.
Milburn is searching for obstacles to knock down. Care leavers will get back the education maintenance allowances (EMA) for staying in school or college, with plans to spread this to all who used to qualify before the Tories axed them – that is, every sixth-former on free school meals. “Just paying for buses to stay in college is £4 a day, £20 a week: too much for those families,” he tells me. Abolishing another obstacle, the government will end young people’s loss of 55p from their benefit for every £1 they earn when they do get a job.
A good omen is the optimism of FE colleges, after years of despair at turning away 16- and 17-year-olds for lack of spaces and teachers. These neglected gardens of second chances for all those failed by Gove-stricken schools are the mainstay of this whole plan. Today, they celebrate being told they can now take as many students as they want. David Hughes, head of the Association of Colleges, closely involved in the Milburn plan, expects colleges to be funded to take tens of thousands more. He wants funding for colleges to do their own social outreach to missing young people. “We can go and find them,” he says. “Many have no adult to ask what to do.” Will this at last be FE’s phoenix moment, after years of neglect of the half not destined for university?
New FE pre-apprenticeship courses will prepare the young for twice as many apprenticeships on offer. The government will redirect existing subsidies to companies hiring new young starters, banning employers from using these funds to upskill existing staff by, for example, paying for managers to take business degrees. But they get big new incentives to take on Neets, with up to £5,000 for each Neet apprentice.
after newsletter promotion
The price to be paid is thoroughly forewarned. Cuts to health benefits for all but the young with the most severe lifelong disabilities will fund this hoped-for youth revival, leaving them with the pitiful standard universal credit of just £80 a week. But here’s the difference from the Treasury’s previous disastrous attempted £5bn welfare heist. This cut won’t fall until the new offers and supports are in place. That’s confirmed by the PM, Milburn and, on Sunday, by Pat McFadden who, as secretary of state for work and pensions, is the keeper of benefits. “That short-term change is going to be very difficult,” he told Sky. But “it’s really important that people don’t have benefit changes before support is in place. That’s the right way round to do this.”
Is that convincing? It helps that Milburn warns not to expect a financial payback from welfare cuts for a decade. This is not about saving money but saving young life chances. Ministers stoutly defend the young against those who brand them idlers and snowflakes. And that is the political dividing line the Tories relish, as they brandish a £36bn benefit axe at the young while rewarding the old with tax cuts. The public do want benefit cuts, but they also know the damage done by the last Tory assaults on the young. There’s the battle line.
It’s for Labour and Milburn, who will remain in post to oversee all of this, to prove, with falling Neet numbers, the value of good social investment. If even half these plans work, that will be a great social advance – a generational shift from appeasing the old to finally directing hope and resources towards the young. And it will be about time.
-
Polly Toynbee is a Guardian columnist
-
Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here.


