Close Menu
NCIJ Network NCIJ Network
    What's Hot

    OpenAI seeks to one-up Anthropic with new customer privacy protections

    August 20, 2026

    Elementor Pro Flaw Could Let Unauthenticated Attackers Upload PHP and Execute Code

    August 20, 2026

    HYPE Price Jumps 20% on Trump Hyperliquid US Signal

    August 20, 2026
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Trending
    • OpenAI seeks to one-up Anthropic with new customer privacy protections
    • Elementor Pro Flaw Could Let Unauthenticated Attackers Upload PHP and Execute Code
    • HYPE Price Jumps 20% on Trump Hyperliquid US Signal
    • Netanyahu Is Hoping for Trump’s Endorsement Ahead of Key Israeli Election
    • What CNN’s Pamela Brown said about going aboard USS Lincoln
    • Russian forces kill 9 in Ukraine as Zelenskyy faces pressure over elections | Russia-Ukraine war News
    • Captured Ukrainian-born soldiers tell BBC why they fought for Russia
    • I replaced my Samsung with the Google Pixel 11 Pro Fold – a week later, I’m going back
    • About
      • Our Team
      • Editorial Policy
      • Editorial Independence
      • International Support
    • Trust & Standards
      • AI Usage Policy
      • Conflict of Interest Policy
      • Corrections Policy
      • Ethics Policy
      • Fact-Checking Policy
      • Source Protection
    • Get Involved
      • Guide for Sources
      • Support Independent Journalism
    • Legal
      • Cookie Policy
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms of Use
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    NCIJ Network NCIJ Network
    Thursday, August 20
    • Home
    • World
    • Ai
    • Business
    • Politics
    • Health
    • Crypto
    • Science
    • Technology
    • Cybersecurity
    • Defense & Security
    • Economy
    • Energy
    • Europe
    • More
      • Fact Check
      • Investigations
      • Opinion & Analysis
      • Environment
    NCIJ Network NCIJ Network
    Home»Fact Check

    UNICEF report didn’t disprove famine in Gaza, contrary to claims

    NCIJ NETWNCIJ NETWORKBy NCIJ NETWNCIJ NETWORKAugust 20, 2026 Fact Check No Comments12 Mins Read
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    Claim:

    A summer 2026 UNICEF report “dismantled” the “lie” that there is or was a famine in Gaza.

    Rating:

    Context

    A July 2026 UNICEF report found the acute child malnutrition rate had recently dropped in Gaza, but largely because of humanitarian aid assistance. UNICEF said food insecurity remains high in Gaza and that malnutrition rates could rise again without sustained peace and humanitarian aid. This report does not contradict an August 2025 determination by the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification, of which UNICEF is a technical partner, that Gaza was officially suffering a famine at that time.

    In August 2026, a rumor circulated online that new acute child malnutrition data from UNICEF — the United Nations’ agency that provides humanitarian and developmental aid for children — “dismantled” the “narrative” that a famine had occurred, or was occurring, in Gaza.

    Various U.N. agencies, including UNICEF, reported in August 2025 that famine had been confirmed in Gaza for more than half a million people in and around Gaza City. The agencies said famine is declared when thresholds for extreme food deprivation, acute malnutrition and starvation-related deaths are surpassed.

    A year later, some social media users questioned those findings based on alleged new data. For example, one Instagram account wrote, in part (archived), “The World Called It a Famine in Gaza. UNICEF’s Own Data Says Otherwise.” The post includes an image of an incorrectly drawn map of the Middle East that purportedly shows each country’s acute malnutrition rate for children under age 5.

    The full text of the post reads:

    The World Called It a Famine in Gaza. UNICEF’s Own Data Says Otherwise:

    A new survey shows Gaza has one of the lowest acute child malnutrition rates in the world: A UNICEF-coordinated survey found that acute malnutrition rates among children in Gaza range from just 0.2% to 0.8% – lower than Egypt (3.3%), Jordan (2.3%), Syria (12.2%), and even some European countries. These are not Israeli government figures. This is the UN’s own data, collected using standard WHO methodology.

    The famine narrative was one of the most damaging lies spread against Israel. UNICEF just dismantled it.

    It should be noted that the caption and the image list different percentages for Gaza. The post’s caption says Gaza’s acute malnutrition rate is between 0.2% and 0.8%, while the map graphics say it’s 1.3%.

    Other posts on Facebook (archived) and Instagram (archived) make the same claim that new UNICEF child malnutrition data refutes the existence of a famine in Gaza. 

    In short, the referenced UNICEF data does not contradict previous declarations by the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification — commonly referred to as the IPC — that there was a famine in Gaza. Therefore, we’ve rated the claim false.

    The “new” UNICEF data refers to an authentic July 2026 snapshot of data a UNICEF-led team is continuously collecting and updating. The Instagram post’s caption accurately describes the data for various Gaza Strip governorates in that snapshot, although it lacks the context of the data’s purpose as a reference for on-the-ground humanitarian aid providers and ignores separate food insecurity data. 

    This authentic data does not show that there is currently a famine in Gaza as of this writing, but it also does not disprove that there was previously a famine in Gaza — which is consistent with the U.N.’s position.

    “The bottom line is, both findings stand: Famine was confirmed in August 2025, and acute malnutrition among children has fallen since,” Kurtis Cooper, chief of media at UNICEF, told Snopes over email. “That improvement is a product of the assistance delivered in between, post-ceasefire, and not evidence that it was unnecessary.” 

    Source of the data referenced in claim

    The referenced data appears to originate from a slideshow presented at the U.N.-led State of Palestine Nutrition Cluster coordination meeting on July 22, 2026. 

    Snopes first became aware of the slideshow through this Reddit comment. We were able to verify its legitimacy by going to the State of Palestine Nutrition Cluster’s page on ReliefWeb — a digital service of the U.N.’s Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs — and clicking on the “National Level Cluster Coordination Meeting minutes” link. The slideshow can be found within the July 22, 2026, meeting folder (archived). It is titled “SoP Nutrition Cluster Coordination Meeting 22 July 2026 … Gaza Nutrition SMART Survey Result.”

    The cluster team is staffed by UNICEF employees, which explains why the data is being attributed to the agency.

    Cooper confirmed that the details of the recent nutrition survey were shared online via a PowerPoint presentation for the members of the nutrition cluster, which he said is a U.N.-led group that coordinates organizations providing nutrition assistance. The survey, Cooper said, measured conditions in mid-2026, more than nine months after the IPC confirmed famine in Gaza in August 2025.

    The survey “does not tell us what conditions were in August 2025, and it was never designed to,” Cooper said.

    What the slideshow, survey say

    The slideshow includes a survey, of which the stated goal was, “To assess the nutritional status of children aged 0–59 months and women of reproductive age (15–49 years) and identify key contributing factors to malnutrition across the Gaza Strip to inform the humanitarian response” (Page 6).

    The findings applied to the 83% of the Gaza population (roughly 1.72 million people) living in areas aid workers could access roughly up to the date of publication: July 22, 2026. The remaining 17% of the population (roughly 358,000 people) were still within either buffer zones or a militarized zone that were inaccessible to the aid workers who conducted the survey (Page 9).

    The data from the Instagram post’s caption claims acute child malnutrition rates in Gaza range from 0.2% to 0.8%. This aligns with a range for one measure from the slideshow’s survey data: wasting by Weight-for-Height Z-score (the graph on the left on Page 12). That graph shows the range of GAM rates (meaning total acute malnutrition rates) among the governorates is from 0.2% in Khan Yunis and Rafah to 0.8% in Gaza and North Gaza.

    However, the data from the most “programmatically useful indicator,” as described by the slideshow on Page 13, places the rates between 0.7% and 2%, depending on the governorate that aid workers had access to. This indicator includes both WHZ data and another measure for acute malnutrition in children, Mid-Upper Arm Circumference.

    The rates for stunting (Page 14) — which the slideshow says “points to longer-term nutritional stress and repeated deprivation beyond immediate wasting” and identifies as the “main child nutrition concern” in Gaza” — are between 11% and 13.5%, again depending on the governorate.

    This data matches a July 23, 2026 analysis by the IPC, a global initiative with numerous stakeholders, including U.N. agencies such as UNICEF, that seeks to inform decisions through greater food security and nutrition analysis — which found that acute malnutrition across the Gaza Strip is low or “acceptable” (see the right-most map, Page 1). The IPC is the same international partnership that on Aug. 22, 2025, declared a part of Gaza was officially experiencing a famine (see “Key highlights,” PDF Page 4).

    What UNICEF says

    On July 23, one day after the slideshow was, per Relief Web, presented at the meeting, UNICEF reported that IPC’s analysis from the same day “shows improvements in food security and child nutrition across the Gaza Strip,” but warned that this improvement “remains fragile” because that progress is “driven largely by expanded access to humanitarian food, nutrition, agricultural and health assistance.” According to UNICEF, the majority of Gaza’s population is dependent on humanitarian aid.

    UNICEF wrote that while the analysis highlights how quickly conditions can improve when humanitarian aid is ramped up, sustained peace, aid funding and access are necessary to prevent the improvement from reversing. Both UNICEF and IPC highlighted that food insecurity remains high across the Gaza Strip.

    UNICEF made no reference to prior famine declarations, nor did it suggest in any way that these current conditions are incompatible with the famine it had previously declared.

    Cooper, the spokesperson for UNICEF, told Snopes that the situation in Gaza has improved because of the expansion in humanitarian assistance between August 2025, when there were severe access constraints and supply disruptions for humanitarian aid groups in Gaza, and mid-2026. 

    “It reflects improvements in conditions rather than evidence that the assistance or the earlier famine classification was unwarranted,” Cooper said.

    Gaza famine

    In August 2025, UNICEF said more than half a million people in Gaza were experiencing famine, again referencing an IPC analysis. That analysis refers to a snapshot similar to the above July 23 IPC analysis, as well as a report on the Famine Review Committee’s review of IPC’s findings at that time. (The IPC calls upon the FRC to independently review its analyses, finding potential or ongoing famine conditions wherever they may occur.)

    At that time, the IPC and FRC agreed that famine was actively occurring in Gaza Governorate, which is largely made up of Gaza City, and could occur in two other governorates aid workers could access within the following few weeks (see “Key highlights,” PDF Page 4). While the IPC and FRC did not extend the famine label to North Gaza Governorate due to limited evidence at the time, it did note that conditions there were likely equal to or worse than the conditions in Gaza Governorate (see the bold sections at the bottom of PDF Page 4). 

    Later in August, the IPC released another report, seeking to answer questions about its decision to declare famine conditions in Gaza Governorate. In that follow-up report, the IPC noted that it used a dataset provided by the Nutrition Cluster — the same UNICEF-led group that is the source of the data in the above social media posts — as evidence for famine in the territory (Section 3, PDF Page 2).

    It noted that the cluster’s data found one measure of acute child malnutrition — GAM by Mid-Upper Arm Circumference, which differs from the measure (GAM by Weight-for-Height Z-score) suggested in the social media posts — increased from 10.1% to 16.4% in Gaza Governorate within three weeks (PDF Page 3).

    At that time, the amount of humanitarian aid that was making it into Gaza was limited by Israel’s offensive military operation in the territory. The first phase of a ceasefire between Israel and Hamas began on Oct. 10, 2025. However, hostilities have continued since, which UNICEF has condemned.

    In December 2025, the FRC released another report reviewing IPC’s August analysis that Gaza Governorate was experiencing famine. In that report (PDF Page 2), the FRC reiterated that famine conditions existed in Gaza Governorate “during the July to mid-August period.” It did not state that it or the IPC believed famine conditions lasted beyond then and past the date of the ceasefire. Snopes could find no evidence of the IPC and UNICEF claiming that the current conditions in Gaza equate to a famine.

    That report also highlights the distinction between IPC analyses and the Nutrition Cluster’s surveillance system (see Paragraph beginning “Fifth,” PDF Page 4). While the IPC’s analyses are designed to be consensus-building processes that consider a wide range of evidence and contributing factors, the Nutrition Cluster’s surveillance system continuously monitors the outcomes of ongoing responses and reporting data as it becomes available in order to meet the needs of aid partners.

    Data entry and cleaning of the Nutrition Cluster system, which the IPC and FRC both use for their analyses, happens in an ongoing, rolling basis. The Nutrition Cluster may retrospectively add and process data for a given time period as information becomes available to it. 

    AI-generated map

    Many of the posts featuring the claim in question include a map apparently showing the data referenced in the posts’ captions. There are a few issues with the map that are immediately noticeable.

    As noted near the top of this article, one is that the data from the captions does not match the data on the map. The captions claim Gaza’s acute child malnutrition rate is between 0.2 and 0.8%, whereas the map says Gaza’s rate is 1.3%.

    The other glaring error is that the map is not geographically accurate. 

    In reality, Gaza has a border with Egypt. In the map, Egypt is detached from Gaza in a southeasterly direction. The West Bank has also been moved north to have a border with Lebanon that does not exist in real life. Kuwait, which sits between Iraq and Saudi Arabia, does not appear at all on the incorrect map, while the portion of Iran does not match the actual shape of that part of the country.

    These nonsensical mistakes are usually made by generative artificial intelligence tools.

    The data shown in the map graphic appears to be based on the primary data tab of the “Joint data set including survey estimates (2025 edition)” spreadsheet downloadable on this UNICEF page, titled, “Child Malnutrition,” which lists historical data not representative of the present situation in 2026. 

    There is no entry solely for Gaza in the spreadsheet, but there is joint data for the Palestinian territories (both Gaza and the West Bank) from 2020 that found their combined wasting rate was at 1.3% at the time. (This data can be found by searching for the ISO code “PSE” and highlighting Row 2,639, Column W, to see the combined “Wasting” percentage for men and women).

    Not all of the data perfectly matches entries from that spreadsheet, but some do. The 2.3% rate for Jordan (ISO code “JOR”) matches the spreadsheet’s wasting entry for the country from 2023. Iraq’s (ISO code IRQ) 3.9% rate appears to match the spreadsheet’s 2018 underweight data (Column Z) for the country. 

    Many of the countries’ rates on the map (Egypt, Iran, Iraq, Jordan, Lebanon, Saudi Arabia, Sudan, Syria and Yemen) match Global Hunger Index data measuring wasting rates by WHZ for children under age 5. Global Hunger Index is a multi-stakeholder, peer-reviewed annual report that aims to measure and track hunger across the globe.

    For further reading, Snopes wrote about the famine in Gaza in August 2025, shortly after the FRC officially classified the conditions in Gaza Governorate as such.

    claims contrary Didnt disprove famine Gaza Report Unicef
    NCIJ NETWNCIJ NETWORK
    • Website

    Keep Reading

    What CNN’s Pamela Brown said about going aboard USS Lincoln

    Unraveling claim Hakeem Jeffries took $300K from healthcare PACs before opposing Medicare for All

    Stripe didn’t really buy OpenRouter because of the ‘singularity’

    Real shirt that confuses Flock cameras, other surveillance tech hasn’t been sold for years

    Trump said he ‘probably’ wouldn’t have rescued 10-year-old from drowning

    Indonesian earthquake video compilation includes old clips from Philippines and Taiwan – Full Fact

    Add A Comment
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Editors Picks

    OpenAI seeks to one-up Anthropic with new customer privacy protections

    August 20, 2026

    Elementor Pro Flaw Could Let Unauthenticated Attackers Upload PHP and Execute Code

    August 20, 2026

    HYPE Price Jumps 20% on Trump Hyperliquid US Signal

    August 20, 2026

    Netanyahu Is Hoping for Trump’s Endorsement Ahead of Key Israeli Election

    August 20, 2026
    Latest Posts

    DHS Official Resigns, Citing ‘War on Immigrants’

    July 27, 2026

    Police make inquiries after Farage reports Polanski post for ‘inciting murder’ | Nigel Farage

    July 27, 2026

    A Japanese town wrestles with identity after protests over its first mosque

    July 27, 2026

    Subscribe to News

    Get the latest sports news from NewsSite about world, sports and politics.

    NCIJ Network is an independent digital news platform delivering trusted investigative journalism, European and global news, in-depth analysis, and fact-based reporting with accuracy, transparency, and integrity.

    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest YouTube

    OpenAI seeks to one-up Anthropic with new customer privacy protections

    August 20, 2026

    Elementor Pro Flaw Could Let Unauthenticated Attackers Upload PHP and Execute Code

    August 20, 2026

    HYPE Price Jumps 20% on Trump Hyperliquid US Signal

    August 20, 2026

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.