Reading Time: 2 minutes
Two weeks ago, I made the hour and 45-minute haul to the tip of the Door Peninsula, where I queued for the first come, first served car ferry to Washington Island.
As the wind whipped my face during the 30-minute crossing, I considered that it might have been my most elaborate reporting trip.
It culminated in the story we published today on the island’s large contingent of homeschoolers. A fascinating dynamic is unfolding: For the most part, it’s not that homeschooling families have a beef with the local public schools, but their choices add challenges to an already-struggling district. I traced how these modern homeschoolers defy persistent stereotypes while working to coexist alongside public school families.
Telling that story meant visiting residents in person, learning details you can’t gather over phone or Zoom.
If I didn’t make the effort to come to their town, look them in the eye, sip coffee with them and explain my interest in their perspectives, I wouldn’t have gained the trust of two of the homeschooling moms in my story.
Because I was there, I saw the district’s administrator banter with a local homeschooling mom who formerly taught at the school — an example of the nuanced relationship between the two camps. I saw the mutual respect between two people who make different choices — not animosity, as one might assume.
Being there allowed me to pick up on other important details, like a banner pleading for donations for a new school gym. It’s small, but it helps readers picture the consequences of the district’s tight budget.
Perhaps most importantly, I wouldn’t have gotten to hold one resident’s duck while visiting her farm.
Showing up allows us to give readers a deeper understanding of Wisconsin’s communities. It’s one of the things Wisconsin Watch does best. I hope you learn something new by reading.

Wisconsin Watch is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom. Subscribe to our newsletters for original stories and our Friday news roundup.
Why we show up: Reporting from Washington Island is a post from Wisconsin Watch, a non-profit investigative news site covering Wisconsin since 2009. Please consider making a contribution to support our journalism.


